
Thurgood Marshall Center: Rows of chairs and light refreshments were set up in a sleepy auditorium. Scuff marks lined the floor between two hoops as people trickled in past check-in tables staffed by eager volunteers. It was the first of many Ward 1 townhalls set up by the Aparna Raj campaign following a hard-fought primary win. With the general election ahead, Aparna wasn’t taking the almost-certain victory for granted. She was there to engage her constituents, to find the issues that matter to them.
In a place as diverse as Ward 1 — where millionaires live next to the destitute, where national, racial, ethnic, political, sexual, and gender identity all coexist in a fine melange — the question “what makes you proud of your neighborhood?” can inspire many different answers. Many, it seems, are not too proud of their neighborhoods, as they advocate for policies that seek to limit our community’s potential and diminish its vital spark.
This particular townhall sought to address residents of U St., Shaw, and Ledroit Park. The U St. Neighborhood Association sent a representative to advocate for the formation of a business improvement district (BID) to address persistent trash and litter. Even the Neighborhood Association representative contends these functions should be addressed by government, as BIDs have proven to cede too much control over public life to private interests. She admits there are other options, such as a neighborhood management authority that would serve to better protect public interests. “But that could take two years!”, her voice rose through thin streaks of light, flowing through papered-over windows. Of course, she and her children “don’t have two years!” to wait for litter abatement; her wail closed out the Oscar-worthy performance.
While the Downtown BID liquidates homeless encampments around MLK Library, a place of vital social services, the U St. Neighborhood Association advocates for further cession of public control of public services in not just U St. but Columbia Heights as well, where a neighborhood management authority is at least being considered. Here we see the persistent cycle of starve the beast and privatize the corpse playing out on our local level.
It didn’t stop there, as a local resident, who seemed to take townhalls as sport, contended that he was there to hold Aparna accountable and would meet her as an honest broker if she met him as the same. He said that while he opposed the National Guard’s presence on our streets out of principle, it sure was nice that they deterred people from littering. Incidentally, he didn’t see a conflict between that point and his larger point that people were still littering at a large enough scale to warrant complaint. He went on to argue with Aparna’s response that armed military patrols as “litter deterrent” was a misuse of federal resources and an active breach of DC’s home rule sovereignty. “Now see, you’re already arguing with me…” he said, as nervous disapproving murmurs and an admittedly overzealous “That’s WILD” from my own mouth filled the space.
It was clear to people in the room that these proposals are as outlandish as they are unhinged, but still the group response was stifled. The group lacked the permission structure they needed to speak out, and without social actors, the word of the reactionary crank wins out. No one feels good denouncing a neighbor in a room full of otherwise well-meaning people, but without a primed audience we’re leaving our socialists in office (SIOs) hanging out to dry. As we seek to leverage our influence with SIOs, we’d do well to remember what got us to the point of being able to propose the greatest slate of social reform since the days of Marion Barry. To abandon our SIOs after all the hard work of canvassing, phone banking, and sloganeering for them is to abandon the political project in its infancy.
We cannot content ourselves with wielding public power without preserving its source; after all, this wouldn’t be the first social movement to flame out due to lack of persistent activist support. No, achieving victory just means the game changes, and tactics and strategies must change with it. All cementing victory in the general election means is that we must move our electoral capacity off the streets and into gymnasiums, schools, and churches. We need to support our SIOs in shaping public discourse. If we allow the reactionaries to set the agenda, we cede control of public policy, and that can never be allowed.